On his birthday, Stefan is surprised by a visit from Lexi, one of his oldest friends. Elena and Jenna are surprised by a change in Jeremy’s behavior. Caroline tries to get his medallion back from Bonnie.
After reading the journal left by one of the Gilbert ancestors, Jeremy is inspired to return to sketching fantasy creatures. Matt and Caroline continue to hang out together. Alaric steps in to help.
Jeremy gets a break from the new history teacher. Bonnie and Caroline continue to argue over the medallion, and hold a séance to help them decide what to do; the results are stranger than any of them expected.
On his birthday, Stefan is surprised by a visit from Lexi, one of his oldest friends. Elena and Jenna are surprised by a change in Jeremy’s behavior. Caroline tries to get his medallion back from Bonnie.
Elena tries to convince Jeremy to stay away from Vicki. Caroline gives Bonnie a necklace she took from Damon. Matt takes Vicki to the high school’s haunted house, but the evening soon takes a terrifying turn.